So above are all the shades that I own...I know it's a bit much
The shades above from left to right are: Sunglasses, Sweet Wishes, and Salt Water
The shades above from left to right are: Summer Love, Beach Resort, Summer Time, Limeade, and Spring
The shades above from left to right are: Vacation, Tropical Bliss, Bikini Time, Cherry Blossom, and Pretty in Pink
The shades above from left to right are: Relaxation, Sand Castles, Desert Sun and Popsicle
The last three shades from left to right are: Waves, Iridescent Light, and Sea Shells.
So the shade that I was talking about being a dupe for the NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil in Milk is the last shade on the right. As you can see from the swatch below it is almost identical. Can you tell which is which? The bottom one is LA JEP :). Like I said they are almost virtually identical. Even in consistency and longevity.
PROS: They are no slip, pigmented, greatly priced, almost no creasing (they do crease a bit with out the use of primer but with primer I saw almost no creasing), and they are very smooth and creamy.
CON: There is one con. The smell! I don't know if it's just me but these smell really strange. Like a mixture of plastic and roses. Anyway, the quality and price are enough for me to over look this part but I thought I would throw it out there.
I hope this was helpful if anyone was looking for great affordable eye bases or just wanted to add a fun way to spice up there day to day makeup routine. Thanks for reading :)